AI Content Quality · How to

AI article quality checklist: 30 checks before you hit publish

Part of the guide Does AI content rank on Google? What Google's own policies say

Use this checklist as the last gate before an AI article goes live. It has 30 pass or fail checks in seven gates: purpose, accuracy, added value, policy, links, readability and metadata. Any failure in the first four gates blocks publishing. Failures in the last three get fixed before publishing but rarely mean rewriting the article.

How to use this checklist

Run it after editing, not instead of editing. Editing improves a draft; this checklist decides whether it ships. Each item is a yes or no question with a concrete test, so two people running it on the same article should get the same answer.

The gates follow Google's own guidance on AI content: accuracy and review first, then value, then the details that appear in search results. Background on why those come first is in the pillar, does AI content rank on Google. If you need the editing method itself, see how to edit AI articles before publishing.

Copy the list into your CMS, a spreadsheet or your project tool and tick each item per article.

Gate 1: Purpose (blocking)

  1. The article answers one clear search question. Test: you can write that question in one line, and the first paragraph answers it.
  2. The first paragraph gives the answer in two or three sentences, with a number or named thing where the topic has one.
  3. The format matches what searchers expect. Test: search the keyword; if the top results are step by step guides, this is too.
  4. You would publish it if search engines did not exist. Google's helpful content page calls the "Why" question "perhaps the most important." If the only reason for the page is a keyword, fail it.

Gate 2: Accuracy (blocking)

  1. Every number, price, date, name and quote has been checked at a primary source. Google says it is "critical to manually factcheck and review all AI-generated content."
  2. Prices and limits carry "as of [month year]".
  3. Every quote can be found word for word in its source.
  4. No unverified claim remains. Anything you could not verify was cut or softened.
  5. Health, legal or financial claims were read by someone qualified, or there are none.
  6. Sources are listed on the page with the date accessed, for every external fact.

The method behind gate 2 is in AI content fact checking, step by step.

Gate 3: Added value (blocking)

  1. The article contains at least one thing the top five results do not: your data, a worked example, a tested setting, a clear recommendation or a documented exception.
  2. It is not a summary of other pages. Test: remove every sentence that paraphrases a competing article. Is something useful left?
  3. It says when the advice does not apply.
  4. It is not a near copy of another page on your site. Test: compare headings with your closest existing article; if they could be swapped, merge instead of publishing.

Gate 4: Policy (blocking)

  1. No link was placed for ranking purposes, traded, bought or inserted by a link network. Google's link spam policy names "Excessive link exchanges" and "Using automated programs or services to create links to your site."
  2. No hidden text or links. No links on single characters, no off-screen or zero-size text. See hidden links in AI blog tools.
  3. Paid or sponsored links carry rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow".
  4. Your publishing pace is one your team can review. If articles go live faster than anyone reads them, you are drifting toward scaled content abuse.
  1. Two to five internal links to genuinely related pages, with anchors that say what the reader gets.
  2. Every external link resolves and supports the sentence it is in.
  3. No links to sites you would not recommend in person.

Gate 6: Readability (fix before publishing)

  1. Headings read as a usable table of contents.
  2. Each section opens with its answer.
  3. Tables are used when three or more named things are compared.
  4. No stock AI phrases from your never list and the voice matches your guide. See brand voice for AI writing.
  5. Someone read it aloud, or listened to it, and fixed what sounded wrong.

Gate 7: Metadata (fix before publishing)

Google's guidance says AI review "also applies to metadata like title elements, meta description elements, structured data, and alternate texts for images."

  1. Title tag is accurate, not exaggerated, and about 60 characters or fewer.
  2. Meta description says what the reader gets in about 140 to 160 characters.
  3. Image alt text describes the image, not the keyword.
  4. Structured data matches the visible page (dates, FAQ text, author) and validates in Google's Rich Results Test.

What is deliberately not on this list

Three things people often add, and why we leave them off:

  • An AI detector score. Google has not said it uses one, and published studies find detectors unreliable. See do AI content detectors matter for SEO.
  • A target word count. Google's helpful content page: "Are you writing to a particular word count because you've heard or read that Google has a preferred word count? (No, we don't.)"
  • Keyword density. Gate 1 already checks the article answers the query. Counting keyword repeats encourages the stuffing Google's spam policies name.

Running the checklist in a team

Split gates by skill. A subject expert signs off gates 2 and 3, an editor runs 1, 5 and 6, and whoever publishes runs 4 and 7. Record who passed each gate and when, so a failure later can be traced. Our human review workflow for AI blog posts covers roles and approval steps in more detail.

Re-run gates 2 and 7 every time you refresh an article. Prices, limits and policy pages change, and the "Last updated" date should only change when the content did.

Where Postbing covers parts of the list

Postbing handles some checks automatically on every article: a fact check against research sources (claims cited, softened or removed), link checks that remove links to the owner's competitors, cap links per paragraph and unlink dead links, and meta title, description, FAQ and schema generation. It never adds link exchanges or hidden links, which covers items 15 and 16 for anything Postbing inserts.

It does not replace gates 1, 3 and the human half of gate 2. Set a site to draft or approval mode so a person runs those before publishing. How we apply these rules to our own articles is in our editorial policy.

FAQ

What makes an AI article good enough to publish?

It answers one clear question, every fact is verified, it adds something the top results lack, and it breaks no spam policy. Links, readability and metadata matter, but they can be fixed quickly.

Which checklist items should block publishing?

Purpose, accuracy, added value and policy. Failing any of those means the article is wrong, redundant or risky, and polishing does not fix that.

Should an AI content checklist include an AI detector score?

We leave it out. Google has not said it uses detector scores, and studies show high error rates, so a score cannot decide whether an article is good.

How often should I re-run the checklist?

On every new article, and again on gates 2 and 7 whenever you update an existing one, since prices, limits and policies change.

Sources

Last updated: November 16, 2026. Spotted an error? Email support@postbing.com and we will fix it. Editorial policy.

Try Postbing free

Postbing reads your site, plans a month of topics from what your customers search for, writes in your voice and publishes to WordPress, Shopify, Webflow or Ghost. Your first article is free.

Try Postbing free

No card needed. No link exchanges, ever.